Was I Crazy to Use AAdvantage Miles on Hotel Redemption?

Maybe I was, maybe I wasn’t. You tell me. I’ve mentioned in my previous post that I was planning on transferring UR points to Hyatt and redeeming  them on Hyatt Regency Bonita Springs resort. Well, a lot can change in one day if you are me! So, it was supposed to be a getaway for my mom when she comes back to US in November. The problem is, I really wanted to take her to Florida Keys.

I think everyone should drive the overseas highway at least once. But we can’t really afford to pay cash for rental and hotels in Key Largo cost an exorbitant amount in points. Not to mention, we would need two rooms. It just makes zero sense IMO to burn 40,000 points X 2 each night for 5 nights, unless you have points coming out of your ears. You would be better off paying cash for condo, cash we don’t really have. There are exceptions, of course, since I used Club Carlson and Wyndham points for two rooms/per night during my parents’ March visit. But in both of those cases, the math was favorable due to BOGO discount and flat-pricing via Wyndham program.

So, I kind of settled my heart on Hyatt in Bonita Springs which I’m sure my mom would love. But… I kept looking for  a way to go to Key Largo, located within 4 hours’ driving distance from our house. Awhile back, I wrote a post on using AAdvantage  miles on hotels but to be honest, it’s not something I ever planned on doing. After all, you can usually get much better value on flights.

But then, AAdvantage program took a turn for the worse: vanishing award availability and devaluation of award chart in March of 2016. So, I’ve decided to check   my options, not really expecting a whole lot. When you do a basic search, the prices are ridiculous. However, if you happen to have an AAdvantage co-branded card like I do,  value proposition improves considerably (hat tip to Kenny from Miles4More). Sorry, Kenny, I keep linking to your post, but it’s really good info for family!

aa hotels

There was one option that caught my attention:

ocean pointe

Hmm, an oceanview  2br/2bath condo, just what we need for five people. The quoted price was 30,000 AAdvantage miles before I logged in as cardholder. Of course, as you can see from TripAdvisor rating, this place is not universally loved, to put it mildly. When I checked individual reviews, they were all over the place. The thing is, every condo is individually owned, so it’s a “hit or miss” kind of thing. From what I’ve seen, most people were moved to a  different unit when they complained, and some condos look truly horrendous, judging from photos. A lot of complaints were about the closure of the pool which was recently undergoing a major renovation. We don’t have to worry about that.

Since we plan on going in November, a slow season, I feel we would have a decent chance at getting assigned to an upgraded unit. I’ll make sure of it. But what is the retail price? Here is the best deal I found for the same exact dates,on a 5-night booking:

ocean pointe trip advisor

So, 103,500 miles can be redeemed for value of $1,150. That comes out to 1.1 CPM (cents per mile). While not spectacular, it allows one to cash out miles on lodging otherwise unattainable via hotel points. So, I went ahead and booked us a 5-night stay at this place. I am taking a bit of a risk, but my mom is a “no frills” person and just wants a hotel by the water. We mostly just need a place to crash in the Keys, and this should suffice. I hope. The rate is good and I would pay it if we had extra cash. But since I’ve got unused miles, we don’t have to.  But what about cancellation policy? Here is what it said in my confirmation email:

aa hotel policy

My stay does not fall between December 17th and January 3rd, and nowhere did it say that the rate is non-refundable. So, it appears, that cancellation or modification are possible in this particular case. Another decent option is to use only 1,000 miles because you get a hefty discount of rack rate:

ocean pointe cash+miles

As you can see, you can save the bulk of your miles and get almost $130 off in exchange for burning only 1,000 miles. Not too shabby! But I went ahead and just used the entire amount. I still have enough miles for 4 one-way tickets to Europe, and beyond that, I just don’t have any plans for AAdvantage program. It’s ironic that at the time everyone in the hobby is scrambling to burn AA miles on business and first class, here I am, redeeming them at a  penny each on hotels. Well, I have always been an oddball.

Buyer beware

Of course, this type of redemption isn’t for everyone. I strongly recommend you think about your future plans and determine whether you can afford to burn your AA stash and get only 1.1 CPM or less. Are you positive you won’t need them for flights in a  near future? In my case, I think I did the right thing. We are going to a place where I wanted to take my mom  to begin with, and saving $1,150 in the process. And we’ll have an apartment with two bedrooms, two bathrooms, kitchen, washer and dryer. Oh, and an ocean view, albeit from a  distance.

Here is who I think is a good candidate for this type of redemption:

1) You have a large family and prefer more space that only a vacation rental can provide. While status can sometimes get you a suite, it will usually have just one bedroom/one bathroom.

2) You have a co-branded AAdvantage card and a huge stash of AA miles that you don’t know what to do with. Currently, the bonus on this offer is 50,000 miles and you can read about it on this page. The offer pays me commission, but be aware that you might be able to get an extra $100 credit when you make a dummy booking on AA.com. Of course, YMMV (hat tip to Will at Doctorofcredit)

3) You are short on cash/hotel points. While getting 1-1.1 CPM per mile isn’t spectacular,  if you acquired them for much less or via sign-up bonuses, it’s certainly worth considering.

4) Your plans are firm. Some hotel reservations can be modified, but it does involve some hassle. In our case, my mom’s ticket to US in November is already bought. Even if one of our kids gets sick, I’ll probably still drag the clan to Key Largo anyway. My mom doesn’t come here that often and they can just be sick at the resort, right? We are not leaving American soil and will  find a local pediatrician if the need arises. We’ve actually done that before when my daughter got an eye infection in Marathon (the middle Keys). Miami hospitals are 1 hour away.

5) You prefer non-chain hotels. There are some very good options, especially if you are going during off-season. Check out this Bradenton (do a  search for Sarasota) mom-and-pop beach hotel:

aa bradneton redemption


Looks nice, doesn’t it? And at a cost of 19,620 AA miles  (includes taxes and cleaning fees) on certain dates, it’s not a bad deal. I’m thinking about going there for 1 night with kids since we live only 1 hour away. And what about that Hyatt in Bonita Springs? I still plan to take my family there for two nights, and will have a post on it later on. But I’ll be booking it with UR points, not AA miles. Stay tuned.

Reader, who used AA miles on hotels before? How did your experience go?

If you found my content beneficial, look at my Support Me page  for ways you can help keep the site running. Also, please, subscribe to receive free blog updates through email and recommend me to your family and friends. You can also follow me on Twitter, like me on Facebook  and download my e-book 


11 thoughts on “Was I Crazy to Use AAdvantage Miles on Hotel Redemption?

  1. Hate to tell you this, but I’d rather stay in the Bonita Springs Hyatt. I loved, loved, loved this resort, the beaches and the area. Very laid back and relaxing. We stayed in Key West four nights at the LaConcha and pretty much hated it. Hotel was nice, but area was not for us. Maybe we just got a bad impression, but we felt like there was nothing to do but go to bars and shop. The beaches were no good at all in Key West. Key Largo may be a whole different vibe with nice beaches though. Don’t mean to question your decision but just my personal opinion.


  2. In taking a second look at the hotel, I bet it will be better than where we stayed. It looks like there is a lot to do like swimming with the dolphins, kayaking, snorkeling, etc. This sounds better suited for a family than La Concha right on Duval Street. I’m sure you’ll have fun!


    • Jennifer, I hear what you are saying! Yeah, this place in Key Largo is supposed to be family-friendly. We may not even drive to Key West because my mom did visit it while on a cruise several years ago. I just mostly want to explore the Keys with her and do a glass-bottom tour to see coral reef. This place looks like something she would like, well, as long as we get a decent unit. Many reviewers loved the resort.
      As far as that Hyatt in Bonita Springs, I absolutely plan to visit it with my family. The problem is, if I took my mom there, my husband would have to stay home. The suite is 1-bedroom (two queens and a sofa bed), and he refuses to sleep in the same room as my mom. He is a private guy, and my mom is kind of “in your face” person. I hope that doesn’t sound mean! Anyway, I do plan to visit it while we have Diamond status and will write a post on it soon.


  3. Thanks for the link, and for the real-life example! As always one size doesn’t fit all, the important thing is that you use the resources you have (or can get easily and cheaply) for what your family actually needs!


    • @Kenny Thank YOU for all the good content you created so far! I know how much time it takes to write these suckers. It took me close to three hours to put this one together from start to finish, but it probably looks like it was written in 5 minutes. Sigh… Blogging looks so easy till you actually start doing it, right? 🙂 Many of your posts are evergreen, and I refer to them on a regular basis.
      As far as this hotel redemption goes, I honestly don’t know if I made the right call. My mom is super excited to visit the Keys, so that’s good! It definitely goes against conventional wisdom, but will allow me to save money. This will be an expensive year in terms of vacation costs, so anything I can do to cut back on cash expenses is a win.


    • Nick, yes indeed! I did look at it, but there were a couple of issues. First, it’s a longer drive from our home. Second, it doesn’t have a beach. But the main problem is that Hyatt place doesn’t have two-bedroom suites. My husband does not want to sleep in the same room as my mom. This place in Key Largo has two separate bedrooms, and we will have a king size bed. He is a big guy, so that’s important! Plus, we will have a full kitchen and other amenities. I don’t know if this was the right thing to do, but it fits our needs.


  4. It always drives me nuts when someone says another place is so wonderful…. *Hyatt”. We all like different things. Some love full service hotels. Some prefer condos. Some must have two bedrooms which you made clear.

    You did well.


    • @Gary Thanks for stopping by! Well, it remains to be seen if I did well, this resort is a bit of “hit or miss.” I like to consider various options and if it was just 4 of us, I probably would book the Hyatt. There are quite a few decent choices in the Keys, but having two bedrooms and two bathrooms was key for this particular trip. I’m very flexible when it comes to hotel brands and my travel patterns reflect it.


  5. Pingback: The Age-Old Question: Hotel Points or Vacation Rentals for Family Vacation? | Miles For Family

  6. Pingback: Reader’s Request: Help Me Maximize My Existing Stash of Miles and Points for a Family Trip to Hawaii | Miles For Family

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s